Interview with Brian Brazil and Paul O'Malley of gNewSense
Michael J. Jordan, Linux Online Staff
November 15, 2006
Irish Free Software developers Brian Brazil and Paul O'Malley have
developed a new distribution, appropriately named gNewSense. Made
with the philosophy of Debian and the structure of Ubuntu, it aims to
be the freest distribution out there. It's so 'free', that it earned an
official endorsement from the Free Software Foundation. Linux Online is
grateful to Messrs. Brazil and O'Malley for taking time out of their
busy schedules to answer a few questions about their project.
Michael Jordan, Linux Online:
Was the endorsement by the FSF something you were working on with them
or did this come as a pleasant surprise?
Brian Brazil / Paul O'Malley:
We did not approach them, they approached us, when they did we were
excited about working with them. It was very pleasant as we had not got
great hosting in terms of bandwidth as we had turned to bit torrent to
do the distribution initially.
MJ:
Has Richard Stallman personally given his approval to the distribution?
Brazil/O'Malley:
Richard has always held that there should be room for all free distros.
An interesting point perhaps is that I can confirm that Richard is
currently using Ututo. However I do know a good few other people in the
FSF are using gNewSense.
MJ:
When you boot up gNewSense, it looks, on the surface, to be Ubuntu
without its logos. Could you explain why it's really *not* Ubuntu?
Brazil/O'Malley:
The kernel differs in that it is missing the firmware, and the
restricted modules found upstream, our repositories only contain Free
Software. Of course we would prefer if people did not add Non Free
Software to our mix, no doubt some people will, however they should be
aware that we neither support or encourage this kind of activity.
MJ:
I'm happy to say that I successfully booted gNewSense on my Thinkpad
laptop (a somewhat finicky machine) and got my wireless card running.
What kind of feedback have you been getting? Have people had as much
luck as I have?
Brazil/O'Malley:
That is great, you must tell us the exact model. :-) On a more serious
note, some people are finding issues with their hardware, but I think if
you take a global picture if you are trying gNewSense and it does not
work, you may be aware that you have a hardware issue, and it is your
call at that stage to consider what to do next.
MJ:
And you're also using gNewSense as a base, of sorts, for others to
create their own distribution. Can people really create their own
personalized distros with it? And how would that work?
Brazil/O'Malley:
We are using Builder to allow people the ability to build their own
tuned as they want it distro. To make it work down stream of gNewSense
it would need to be tweaked a little, as it is designed for use with
Dapper. However right now it is used to make gNewSense.
MJ:
I think a lot of pundits out there are probably saying 'Look, another
Linux distribution'. There are some that would argue that we don't need
more distros but more volunteers for existing distros. Why was it more
important for you to create gNewSense instead of say, volunteering to
work on Ubuntu or Debian?
Paul O'Malley:
Let me break that into a few parts.
We don't need more distros is a spurious argument. Obviously there was
an itch and we endeavoured to scratch it.
Technically there is also the fact that we were enthralled with the
prospect of attacking the source of a distro to remove the non free
parts, and see how much of it is still operational. While I say we,
please note that Brian is the lead dev, I am a sysadmin not a coder, I
can hack a little. Ergo I got the community side of the deal.
MJ:
Thanks for taking the time to answer our questions and good luck with
gNewSense development.
Paul O'Malley:
Glad to answer your questions Michael, thanks for your interest in
our project. Lastly if I might pimp the distro a little, if anyone has
the interest in getting involved have a quick look at our website, it
contains things we need help with. http://www.gnewsense.org, with links to our mailing list.
Final Note:
Just for the record, the model of my Thinkpad is the 600X - an oldie but a goodie! And
I got gNewSense running on it - with my LinkSys PCMCIA wireless card and all - with ease.
So if you're a purist and you want to work guilt-free (especially after the Novell-Microsoft pact), then I suggest you try it out.
Michael J. Jordan is the webmaster of Linux Online. He can be reached at Michael.Jordan**AT**linux.org
|